Yeah, storyfinder comms aren't really a good place for discussion. Reading that I kept thinking that nobody ever asks for stories that focus on how Rodney is obviously clueless about physics and engineering no matter what the series claims, because all the technobabble isn't real science and doesn't hold up to what a fifth grader knows about physics. Or how Sheppard is a bad soldier because the military procedures are nothing of the sort. I mean seriously. The medicine and practices are wonky sometimes, because they are there for the SGA-type of not-hard SF, you just have to suspend disbelief, the whole series totally collapses once you try to hold characteres to any realistic standards.